EXCLUSIVE: ‘Renovation Resort’ Stars Reveal Top Tips for Maximizing Your ROI on Home Updates

May 17, 2026 - 03:44

Bryan Baeumler and Sarah McGillivray have seen plenty of renovation wins and a few costly mistakes. The co-hosts of the cabin makeover competition show recently opened up about the strategies they believe give homeowners the best return on investment.

McGillivray, 48, stressed that the first step is always planning. She said many people rush into buying materials or tearing down walls before they have a clear budget and timeline. Her top tip is to spend money on things that improve daily life, like good lighting and durable flooring, rather than trendy finishes that will look dated in a few years.

Baeumler, 52, agreed but added that homeowners should not overlook the bones of the house. He pointed out that upgrading insulation, windows, or the roof often pays off more than a fancy kitchen backsplash. He also warned against over-improving for the neighborhood. If you put a luxury bathroom into a modest home, you might not get that money back when you sell.

Both hosts emphasized the value of doing one project well instead of starting three at once. They see contestants on the show make the same error: trying to do too much with too little time and money. Baeumler said the smartest move is to focus on high-traffic areas like the kitchen and main bathroom, because those rooms influence a buyer's first impression.

McGillivray also noted that small details matter. Simple updates like new cabinet hardware, fresh paint, and modern light switches can change the feel of a room without a big expense. She said the key is to keep the design consistent throughout the house so it feels cohesive, not patched together.

For anyone planning a renovation, the advice from these two is clear: plan ahead, invest in quality where it counts, and resist the urge to follow every trend. That approach, they say, is the real secret to maximizing your return.